Supreme Court Appeal to Stop Covid 19 Vaccinations of Children on the Grounds of Lack of Informed Consent

On July 12, David Egan, Sharon Browne and Emmanuel Lavery gave notice of appeal to the Supreme Court in Ireland to stop the covid 19 vaccinations of children in Ireland on the legal grounds of Lack of Informed Consent by Parents and obtaining Informed Consent by Non Disclosure, False Pretences, Fraudulent Misrepresentation, Deception and Fraud.

The plaintiffs, David Egan, Sharon Browne and Emmanuel Lavery, had lodged a motion in the High Court seeking a conditional injunction to stop the covid 19 vaccination of children until such time as full Informed Consent could be given by parents and guardians but, they argue, Judge Michael Twomey did not allow them to present and argue the basis of their case in full court hearings.

They had also lodged a second motion in the High Court to address:

the denial of protective costs to them

the use of the judgment on costs to pre-judge and prejuidice and effectively block any court hearings on Informed Consent and the Injunction which was the basis of the whole court case

the recusal of the Judge for bias

the denial of full hearings on Informed Consent and the Injunction sought

They claim that:

costs are not normally charged for Public interest cases […] which involve Constitutional rights of Informed Consent, the right to bodily integrity and the right to life, Constitutional breaches and Human Rights breaches and Environmental protection breaches which adversely affect the Common Good.

Only two of the eleven Preliminary Issues within this Motion on costs were allowed to be partially presented, therefore they argue:

[t]he motion stands as un-presented to the High Court and there can be no final judgment of it. […] There was a denial of the right to ‘audi alteram partem’ and to due process, equality of arms, fair proceedings, and the presentation of prima facie evidence, expert witnesses and witnesses in court, and this fatally affected the outcome of the High Court case. These were Serious breaches of the Irish Constitution of 1937 and national and international human rights laws and this is the subject of [their] appeal to the Supreme Court.

On the substantive issue of informed consent they state:

the Judge again refused to accept as prima facie evidence the 9 pages from Pfizer showing 1,100 types of illnesses, disabilities and deaths caused by the covid19 vaccine which was filed with the FDA in the USA and EMA in Europe and was released under US federal Court order in 2022. This is in Exhibit 1 (word format) which was handed to a Judge in the High Court in Ireland in March 2023. Also Pfizer document Exhibit 2 (word format) was handed to a judge in the High Court in Ireland in March 2023. This document showed 1,223 people had died and 25,000 people suffered nervous system disorders, 8,800 suffered respiratory disorders, 17,000 suffered gastrointestinal disorders, and over 42,000 people had suffered injuries, disabilities and illnesses caused by the vaccine within the first 90 days of the vaccine being given to the general public.

But, this information which Pfizer and the FDA in the USA and the EMA in Europe and the HPRA in Ireland had was NOT given to covid19 vaccine recipients in the USA and in the European Union and not given to parents and guardians. There was a deliberate attempt to hide and conceal this information from the general public including vaccine recipients according to court findings in the USA in 2021, 2022 and 2023. This was and is a clear and obvious breach of Informed Consent for these covid19 vaccinations. A point ignored by the High Court judge but which will be put directly to the judges in the Supreme Court, during the appeal.

In a press release issued following a high court hearing on March 10, 2023 they state that the high court was told that,

Ireland has many thousands of people who were injured, made ill and disabled and some even killed by the covid19 vaccines and boosters but there is no State Compensation Program. There has never been a State Compensation Program for the vaccine injured, ill and disabled and those killed by vaccines, and this is a disgrace and a national scandal. Most of them cannot afford medical tests and treatments. Many thousands of seriously ill people in Ireland are being left in a limbo and have massive medical costs.

Their July 12, ’23 press release outlining their High Court case and the basis for their appeal to the Supreme Court provides a detailed, multi-faceted, evidence based and referenced account of the harm caused by the covid 19 vaccines, evidence of non-disclosure of adverse effects of the vaccines by pharmaceutical companies and evidence of significant increases in excess mortality after covid 19 vaccination, based on official government statistics from many countries and from Eurostat and Euromomo. In their press release they also outlined the obstacles they encountered when attempting to present evidence for their motion on the lack of informed consent and for their claim that by denying protective costs “the judge has gone against court rules, laws and precedents“

Their full press release can be read here.